The State and Development Directions of Polish Waste-to-Energy Plants in Improving R1-Based Energy Recovery Performance

Abstract

The paper presents an analysis of the status and development trends of Polish Waste-to-Energy (WtE) installations in the context of improving the level of energy recovery measured by the R1 indicator of the Waste Framework Directive (R1 is a regulatory indicator of the R1/D10 classification, not the thermodynamic efficiency of the installation). Based on the standardised annual operating energy balances of six mature municipal waste incineration plants from 2020 to 2024 and partial data for 2025, electricity and heat production, auxiliary media consumption and waste fuel parameters were compared, and R1 was calculated in the Ep, Ef, Ew and Ei systems. The R1 values were then compared with heat collection conditions and modernisation implementations (integration with the heating network, exhaust gas condensation, advanced control/predictive algorithms), treating the ‘before/after’ comparisons as an observational assessment, without inferring strict causality. The average R1 for the facilities studied in 2020–2024 was 0.864, with the highest values recorded for installations in Kraków (R1 = 1.123 in 2024). The results indicate that a high and growing R1 is primarily associated with cogeneration and stable heat management in district heating systems, and that upgrades aimed at additional heat recovery and process stabilisation can further support this trend, in line with the ‘energy efficiency first’ principle. A novelty of the study is the standardised, long-term benchmarking of full-scale data for six installations using a uniform R1 methodology.